Threat : Ocean Acidification

Ocean chemistry is changing, and the main focus of attention has been ocean acidification, which occurs when increased CO2 uptake reduces available carbonate ions . Recent projections suggest, under high emission scenarios, that global average pH could decrease from 8.1 to 7.8 by the end of the century. However, ocean acidification hotspots (acidity increasing at a faster rate) occur due to regional factors such as coastal upwelling, changes in discharge rates from rivers and glaciers, sea ice loss, and urbanization.

Ocean acidification is a significant threat to shellfish. The United States the shellfish industry may be losing more than $400 million a year by 2100 as a result of ocean acidification. Acidic ocean waters can inhibit shellfish growth, lower survival rates, and populations. For example, in Chesapeake Bay increased growth rates in crabs, tied to lower pH, can lead to increased predation of oysters. Recent studies suggest that competitive interactions among species may shift, putting shellfish at a relative disadvantage.

According to a 2019 report prepared by a Massachusetts Special Legislative Commission on Ocean Acidification, the Commonwealth is home to some of the most acidification-vulnerable communities in the country. 

WATCH the video series “The Origin and Impacts of Ocean Acidification” from Climate.gov (NOAA)

Oysters are a habitat forming species. If they are harmed by ocean acidification (and pathogens), key habitat may be lost for other species and ecosystem services may be disrupted. For example, oyster reefs can also provide storm surge protection, and their loss can make shorelines more vulnerable to coastal erosion and damage.

Despite Wellfleet Bay’s high rate of primary production, it may be particularly sensitive to the acidification of coastal waters because of anthropogenic disturbance to its fringing salt marshes. About half the coastal marshes around Wellfleet Harbor have been diked and drained since 1909. Salt marsh diking and drainage generates acid sulfate soils and the leaching of low-pH freshwater during ebb tides into the harbor

Ocean Acidification Impacts Relevant to Shellfishing

  1. A decline in calcification rates, leading to slower lipid accumulation rates and thinner, malformed, or eroded shells.
  2. Acidification may favor predators feeding on bivalves.
  3. Acidification may cause a decrease in populations of bivalve species, by potentially inhibiting larval development.

“Oyster farmers and ocean acidification in Washington State”

Implications for Shellfishing

Ocean acidification has the potential to :

  1. Inability to produce seed for shellfish aquaculture
  2. Decrease growth rates and survival rates of shellfish.
  3. Decrease economic value of shellfish and decrease revenue of shellfisherers.
  4. Change how shellfish can be grown and harvested.

Recommended Actions

  1. Connect homes to municipal wastewater system
  2. Close shellfish beds
  3. Educate public
  4. Establish fund for restoring and protecting marshes
  5. Establish policies that promote living shorelines (oyster reefs, salt marshes, seagrass beds)
  6. Establish public land acquisition program for coastal protection
  7. Explore ability to enforce more restrictive regulations (than Wetlands Protection Act, no more armoring)
  8. Evaluate and recommend soft solutions (rather than hard structures) for shoreline protection
  9. Evaluate policies for beach re-nourishment and recommend more environmentally safe strategies
  10. Improve drainage infrastructure
  11. Include strategies in Harbor Management Plan
  12. Increase protection of wetlandsPromote treatment/filtration of surface runoff
  13. Protect wetlands
  14. Purchase coastal lots
  15. Promote alternative wastewater systems (such as composting toilets, Nitrex barriers, and localized cluster wastewater systems)
  16. Improvements to fertilizer controls
  17. Improvements to stormwater run-off control
  18. Removal of man-made tidal restrictions
  19. Require septic upgrades (over time)
  20. Salt marsh restoration, oyster reef restoration, eel grass restoration (storm surge buffering and sustainable water quality/fish spawning habitat improvement)
  21. Treatment/filtration of surface runoff
  22. Restore and protect marshes, eel grasses, and oyster reefs
  23. Retreat from coast
  24. Revise permitting policies
  25. Study and recommend strategies that allow for beneficial transport of sand
  26. Write orders of conditions for new buildings and septic systems